Perseverance
of a People on
the Cusp of Annihilation
______________
This
religious awakening doesn't end in a conversion
by
Caleb Miller
A spiritual pilgrimage sounded like a joke.
I would never have imagined that the sight of people crawling
on their hands and knees for three weeks through snow-covered,
mountainous terrain could prove to be a mentally stimulating
experience. Ordinarily I would have thought that such an extreme
display of piety would have seemed ridiculous and pitiful to
me. However, when I actually witnessed this event, I had the
exact opposite reaction. It would be the first time I ever recognized
religion as being capable of having any truly tangible positive
effects. It was during the summer of 2001 that I was afforded
the rare opportunity to travel to Nepal and Tibet. I was on
break from high school at the time, and while not everyone would
consider a trip into a decimated imperialist state a typical
vacation, I have always been partial to trips that involve a
bit of adventure and physical stress as opposed to so-called
"relaxing" retreats to some spa or a monstrous commercial
tourist attraction in an overcrowded urban metropolis.
Over
the course of a great many years, my father and a few of his
friends have intermittently organized mountain-climbing excursions
and jungle expeditionsa bit of danger in often remote
localesand I had always been eager to join them on one
of these adventures. In previous years, I had been either
simply too young to tag along on such physically demanding
trips or else, due to school or some other unavoidable obligation,
my schedule would not permit an extended absence. This time,
however, my father had scheduled a trip specifically so that
my brother and I could, if we chose, join him on a month long
trek across the Nepalese border and into Tibet. The point
of this particular excursion was to complete a "kora,"
a sort of ritualistic circling around Mount Kailas, a beautiful
snow-capped peak in the Himalayan mountain range that rises
up alone out of a flat desert plain. Not only is Kailas the
spiritual center of Buddhism, Hinduism, and Bon, but it is
also believed by the devout that many deities, including Shiva,
the chief god in Hinduism, and various Buddhas reside above
the mountain. Completion of the kora around the mountain is
the ultimate symbol of worship and physical sacrifice. The
faithful pilgrims who complete the trek have their spiritual
slates wiped clean of any residual sins. And just to seal
the deal and guarantee that one will achieve nirvana, there
is also a lake adjacent to Kailas where even more lifetimes
of sins can be washed away in mere minutes. This cleansing
is believed to be so complete that those who participate in
it thereby spare their souls the eternity of pain and torment
that is reincarnation.
My father, as an ardent "Western" Buddhist (or, as I like
to call him, a fashionable Buddhist who contemplates ancient
philosophies involving such profound concepts as life-as-pain
and anti-materialism in the reclining leather seat of his
climate-controlled luxury vehicle), was more than happy to
lay down a few thousand dollars to journey to this spiritual
epicenter in order to have his soul cleansed. I realize that
this little rant sounded a bit cynical or, at the very least,
very skeptical, but I am an atheist and I hold a great deal
of contempt and even hatred for organized religion and the
resultant dogma. To me, a trip into the Himalayas and the
dense jungles of Nepal sounded absolutely amazing. A spiritual
pilgrimage to the resting-place of the Buddhas sounded like
a joke. The trek itself was incentive enough for me, but I
couldn't help feeling overwhelmingly hypocritical as an atheist
participating in a sacred Buddhist ritual. Little did I know
that this trip would give me an entirely new perspective and
a better understanding of how religion can sometimes, however
rarely, be a good and useful thing.
I won't
be surprised if they seek to exist
To properly
explain how I came to think beyond my vehemently negative
prejudicial stance on religion, I feel I should preface the
details of my journey with a brief history of the Chinese
imperialist policies that have led to the current deplorable
condition of Tibet. In 1949 China invaded Tibet and declared
the country as one of its provinces. Within ten years the
military had secured complete control of the country, forcing
the spiritual and political leader of Tibet, the Dalai Lama,
into exile. As a pacifistic people, most of whom practice
Buddhism, the Tibetans believe all living things are sacred
and therefore put up little to no real resistance against
the violent invasion of the Chinese military. They have refused
to respond in kind, instead favoring civil disobedience. But
non-violent protest only works when the oppressing forces
are not willing to torture and slaughter the protesters. So
from 1949 to the present day, the Chinese have engaged in
a policy of eradication: an attempt to destroy anything Tibetan
and to more fully assimilate Tibet as a true colony of China.
Because Tibetan culture, religion, and nationality are hindrances
to Chinese occupation and total control of Tibet, China has
attempted to wipe these things off the face of the planet.
Even the Tibetan language has become a target; it is being
systematically removed from schools. China has destroyed thousands
of Tibetan villages, temples, and businesses and has built
in their place a vast number of jails and detention centers
where innocent Tibetans are imprisoned, tortured, and "reeducated"
to suit Chinese policy. Prisoners are chained and shackled
so they can be attacked by dogs or have electric cattle prods
shoved into their mouths, rectums, and vaginas. In an attempt
to make the Tibetans a minority in their own country, China
has also implemented a policy of mass immigration sending
waves of Chinese people flooding into Tibet.
I could
go on for pages and pages about the way China exploits the
Tibetan people, from the resources they strip out of the mountainsides
to the areas of the country they use as testing grounds for
nuclear weapons, but I really only want to give you a taste
of the situation. In sum, the Tibetans are a broken people
and because there are no countries that wish to intervene
on behalf of these tortured people (despite the Dalai Lama's
constant, very charismatic diplomatic visits with various
heads of states and an astonishing level of public awareness
and popular support for the Free Tibet movement), I will not
be surprised, if in a decade or two, the Tibetans are no longer
a people at all. They will vanish into thin air with no trace
of their culture left except in dusty museum displays (147-54).
The Tibet of my imagination was an exotic paradise
It took a
while, but my father finally managed to make arrangements with
the Chinese government for our passage into Tibet. The Chinese
government is very wary of allowing foreigners to enter Tibet.
It is even more opposed to allowing entrance to anyone wishing
to perform rituals associated with any of the indigenous religious
customs, so it took a lot of arguing and cajoling on my father's
part, but he finally obtained the paperwork that we needed in
order get us past the military and on our way to Mount Kailas.
Even though we had all of the necessary papers, Chinese spies
followed us everywhere we went. The Chinese government is not
too fond of the idea of foreigners bringing back information
about the daily atrocities perpetrated against the Tibetans
and they certainly don't want anyone inciting revolutionary
thoughts in the minds of the conquered Tibetan people.
Our
initial destination was Katmandu, the bustling jungle capital
of Nepal. After a day of rest and reorientation following our
incredibly long plane flight, we took yet another aircraft to
the eastern city of Nepalganji where we clambered into a tiny
ten-person propeller airplane loaded with cargo and sailed into
the mist-covered Himalayan slopes. We were headed for the alpine
town of Simikot near the Nepalese border into Tibet. Because
there is no runway in Simikot, planes land in a shrub-covered
section of the town located next to a giant precipice. (The
planes taking off get just enough speed so that they won't plummet
to destruction when they reach the edge of the cliff; it's an
exciting sight to say the least.) As the mists parted, our plane
crashed to a halt in the center of the town. The real part of
our journey hadn't even yet begun.
Starting
at Simikot we traversed a little over sixty miles north through
the Himalayan mountain range to a 19,000-foot pass spanning
the border into Tibet.
As we scrambled though the Nepalese section of the Himalayas,
the lush countryside spotted with giant waterfalls and patches
of jungle drastically built up my anticipation of what we would
see upon reaching Tibet. I was already well aware of the fact
that most of the Tibetan landscape is alpine desert, but for
some reason the Tibet of my imagination was an exotic paradise
of beautiful temples and magical towns dotting the steep mountainsides.
It seemed as if this had to be true otherwise it just didn't
make any sense to me why China would invade this little country
and hold onto it with such brutal intensity.
A place where it is harder to breathe than in L.A.
Upon reaching
the pass and descending into Tibet, however, I was quickly surprised
and disappointed to encounter the sobering realities of the
harsh Tibetan landscape. I don't know for certain whether the
landscape was excessively decimated by the Chinese exploitation
of the resources or whether it's just the natural terrain of
such a high elevation country, but the landscape of Tibet is
comparable to that of the moon. The vast majority of the terrain
oscillates between scorching brown dessert and freezing glacial
plains. As a western film enthusiast, I related my experience
to Star Wars. Tibet was a hybrid between the ice planet
of Hoth and the desert planet of Tatooine. Once we crossed into
Tibet, I rode in broken down Land Cruisers and in the back of
a cargo truck eastward bound for a hundred miles or so to the
location of Lake Mansarovar and Mount Kailas. In driving across
a large portion of the country, I was able to observe the condition
of the environment with keen detail. For days on end the landscape
seemed unchanging and the only thing that made me think we were
moving at all was the way our car violently bounced up and down
as we tore across the uneven rocky plains. Red dust, so fine
it could and did penetrate the interior of whichever vehicle
I was occupying, covered the entire landscape. I wrapped my
face with whatever I could find so as not to choke when I had
to breathe. Apparently, there are places where it's harder to
breathe than in the noxious smog-filled city of Los Angeles.
The only
visual relief from the monotony of the landscape was the various
towns where we stopped in order to stretch our legs and purchase
water. And it was these towns that ultimately destroyed my
perception of Tibet as a magical place. Any monasteries or
indigenous villages not burned to the ground by the Chinese
military were quickly decaying and looked as if they could
collapse at any moment. All of the other towns looked like
cheap reproductions of Chinese ghettos. Hundreds of shops,
all crammed together, all with neon signs, and all peddling
cheaply made novelty goods and clothing, lined the garbage-covered
roads. The Chinese government's cultural genocide of the Tibetan
people, which I daily saw evidence of, made me want to vomit
in disgust. In fact, it only took a day or two for me to become
overwhelmed with hatred for China and what they had done to
this virtually defenseless country.
After
days of witnessing China's imperialist policies and the nothingness
of a landscape that would make existentialists reconsider
their beliefs, we finally reached Lake Mansarovar. The lake
sparkled like a sapphire against its desert surroundings.
Off in the distance I could see the solitary peak of Kailas
rising up above the dust and glowing like a giant diamond.
It was one of the first beautiful things I had seen in days
and it was a liberating experience. For a moment I stopped
loathing myself for being such a blatant hypocrite and simply
basked in the astounding beauty of a country I had only minutes
earlier deemed "the worst place on earth." It was finally
time to start the kora around Kailas. Although I was beginning
to feel a slight appreciation for Tibet, I still, in no way,
expected Kailas to have an impact upon my beliefs.
"Even in the snow?"
Prior to
reaching the mountain I was only vaguely aware of how significant
this particular year was in terms of the Buddhist faith and
its relation to Kailas. Apparently, as my father had tried to
tell me early on in the trip, every thirteenth year is auspicious
and if the kora is performed in one of these auspicious years
the lifetimes of sins erased are amplified ten times over. I
have a habit of ignoring most of what my father says, even in
those instances when the information is actually valuable, so
the importance of this thirteenth year never really entered
into my mindat least not until we actually started the
kora and I saw thousands of Tibetans preparing for the same
trip. This mountain which I had previously looked upon as a
ridiculous symbol of delusion suddenly became a symbol of inspiration.
I didn't understand how this mountain in the middle of a giant,
arid desert could draw people in such masses from around the
world. Even more incomprehensible to me was how it could attract
such a vast number of Tibetans, when such a display of faith
put them in grave danger. In an instant, I gained a great deal
of respect for the mountain and it affected me in a way that
all of the books and stories glorifying the sacred peak could
not. This newfound respect, however, represented only a small
change in perspective compared to the realization I would have
on the third day of the kora.
On Kailas,
there is an incredibly steep and rocky pass, usually covered
in snow. It is the highest point on the trek and the most
difficult part of the climbing and hiking. (No one actually
climbs the mountain peak itself, out of respect for the religions
to which it is sacred and because of a "force field" that
supposedly injures anyone who attempts it.) Already absolutely
exhausted from the long trek that lay behind me, that pass
was punishing. As I slowly clambered across the ice and rock
to the top of the incline, I collapsed. My body felt destroyed
but it was liberating and relieving to see the hardest parts
of the journey behind me. It took me several minutes to muster
enough strength to continue with the journey, but as I slowly
lumbered down the other side of the pass I saw what would
forever change my understanding of religion: three tiny black
spots in an ocean of pure blinding white. Along a large snow
covered bank, three Tibetans were on their way to completing
the kora, but they were doing it differently than myself and
the other people I had encountered on the trek. These people
would take three steps forward, drop to their knees in prayer,
and then drag themselves a few feet forward on their bellies.
I asked our guide Tilak what these people were doing and he
explained to me that the extremely pious complete the kora
while prostrating before the gods.
"Even in the snow?" I asked.
"Especially in the snow."
"And how long does it take to complete the kora when they do it like that?" I asked Tilak.
He answered matter-of-factly, "A little over three weeks."
Not even I could stand to take away their hope.
It was a
shocking moment. I couldn't imagine how anyone could spend three
weeks crawling on one's belly through snow and ice and then
up a pass so steep it nearly defeated me completely even though
I climbed it normally. I was overwhelmed with confusion.
My thoughts were racing in a thousand different directions at
once. My initial reaction was to scoff. I thought it one of
the most idiotic, ridiculous things I had ever seen. I asked
myself "Why put yourself through so much discomfort and pain
for something that doesn't even exist?" And that is when I had
my little epiphany. The Tibetan people have absolutely nothing.
They are some of the poorest people I have ever seen. Their
land is so dry as to be incapable of yielding any crops. Their
culture and language have been torn from their grasp. They aren't
even allowed to carry around a picture of their true leader
for fear of death and torture. In a land where the native population
has been virtually destroyed and the remaining people are left
broken with nothing tangible to give them hope, it is natural
that those surviving Tibetans would look to something beyond
their immediate surroundings for solace. Religion and their
beliefs are the only things remaining which they can call their
own and to which they can cling. And cling they do, with amazing
zeal. Not even I could stand to take away the last bit of hope
of a people on the verge of extermination.
Up until
that point I had been entirely confident in my understanding
of religion as an evil tool of control, as something to keep
the masses complacent and ignorant, as something that had
caused so much violence and spurred so many wars that I couldn't
see any way it could benefit civilization. Suddenly, a crack
had appeared in my reasoning. In Tibet, where the people had
been stripped of anything and everything they can call their
own, religion is something positive and motivating. It is
a buoy helping the Tibetan people to keep their heads above
the violent churning ocean that desires to drown them and
their civilization forever. And for that reason I was able
to find a level of respect and appreciation for religion that
would never have been possible had I not seen for myself the
atrocities that occur in Tibet every single day.
Caleb
Miller is a junior in the Film program with the Critical Studies
department. He sometimes plays in a punk band and has an interest
in special effects makeup.
Tofani,
Loretta. "Tibetans Under Chinese Rule." Genocide. Ed.
William Dudley. San Diego: Greenhaven Press, 2001. 147-154.
Rpt. of "Bodies Scarred, Spirits Broken." The Philadelphia
Inquirer. 1996 .